As the conversation around building regulations, energy performance, and environmental standards gains momentum in the UK, I had the pleasure of sitting down with James Hawthorne, an architect deeply involved in the recent consultation on proposed changes. This consultation, which ran from December 2023 to March 2024, was a vital first step in shaping the Future Homes Standard in England, aiming to align energy performance and ventilation standards with the ambitious goals of reducing carbon footprints and enhancing indoor environmental quality.
Focus360 Energy: property compliance services – pre-planning to post-construction. Learn more.
James has been a part of several working groups focused on the integration of sustainable practices within the built environment. His insights offer a unique perspective on the intricacies of these proposed regulations and their potential impacts on the construction industry.
The Consultation Process: A Collaborative Effort
“The initial consultation was quite an extensive process,” James began, reflecting on the months of intense discussions and reviews. “We were looking at a range of proposals, many of which drew inspiration from the Passivhaus standard, known for its stringent energy performance and indoor comfort criteria.”
One of the primary focuses was the development of the Home Energy Model (HEM), a proposed replacement for the Standard Assessment Procedure (SAP). “Like SAP, HEM is expected to underpin a significant number of government policies. The idea is to create a more versatile tool that can adapt to various contexts, from compliance with building regulations to broader policy reporting,” explained James.
Learning from Passivhaus: Principles and Practices
The Passivhaus standard served as a crucial reference point throughout the consultation. “We examined several key aspects of Passivhaus, such as the use of a robust calculation methodology, setting ambitious energy performance targets, and ensuring the continuity of insulation and airtightness,” James noted.
One particularly interesting aspect of the consultation was the debate between absolute and relative energy targets. “Passivhaus sets absolute targets, which can drive the design towards highly efficient forms. However, the current building regulations in the UK favour relative targets, where performance is measured against a notional building. This allows for more flexibility but may not push the boundaries of energy efficiency as much,” he added.
Ventilation and Indoor Air Quality
A significant portion of the consultation also focused on ventilation and maintaining a healthy indoor environment. “The Passivhaus standard advocates for mechanical ventilation with heat recovery (MVHR) systems, which are highly effective in maintaining indoor air quality while reducing heating demand,” James explained.
However, integrating MVHR systems into mainstream building practices presents challenges. “There are concerns about the maintenance and operational aspects of these systems. It’s one thing to design and install them, but ensuring they are used and maintained properly is another. The consultation addressed these issues, aiming to find a balance between promoting advanced systems and ensuring practical usability,” he said.
Moving Towards a New Calculation Methodology
The development of the Home Energy Model (HEM) represents a significant shift in how energy performance is calculated and reported. “HEM is being designed with greater transparency and flexibility. It separates core building physics from policy-specific assumptions, allowing for more accurate and tailored applications,” James highlighted.
This model will align with international standards and offer detailed, half-hourly energy performance simulations. “This granularity is crucial for integrating smart technologies and systems, which are becoming increasingly common in modern buildings,” he added.
The Road Ahead: Summer 2025 and Beyond
While the initial consultation laid the groundwork, the next phase will be crucial. “A second consultation is scheduled for summer 2025, where more detailed standards will be proposed. This will be the time to refine the initial proposals and address any gaps or issues identified during the first round,” James pointed out.
He emphasized the importance of ongoing research and validation. “The transition from SAP to HEM is not just about changing a calculation tool; it’s about ensuring that the new model accurately reflects real-world performance. This requires continuous validation against other models, laboratory data, and actual monitoring data from homes.”
Conclusion: A Balanced Approach
Reflecting on the consultation, James expressed optimism but also caution. “The proposed changes are ambitious and necessary, given our climate goals. However, they must be practical and achievable. The consultation process is about finding that balance—setting high standards while ensuring they are grounded in reality.”
As we look towards the summer of 2025, the insights from professionals like James Hawthorne will be invaluable in shaping a sustainable and resilient built environment in England. The journey towards the Future Homes Standard is a collaborative effort, requiring input from all stakeholders to ensure that the final outcomes are both ambitious and attainable.
Marcia Snyder
Be the first to comment