In the bustling world of building contractors, where deadlines are tight and stakes are high, the art of navigating conflict and resolution is as crucial as the construction itself. Recently, I had the opportunity to sit down with Mark Stanton, an experienced project manager for a leading construction firm, to explore the nuances of conflict avoidance and dispute resolution. Our conversation offered a fascinating glimpse into the practical applications of strategic advice in the construction industry, particularly through the lens of consultancy partnerships, such as those with Edge Consult.
Focus360 Energy: property compliance services – pre-planning to post-construction. Learn more.
Mark Stanton, a calm and articulate professional, has been in the construction industry for over two decades. He has witnessed the evolution of building practices and the increasing complexity of projects. His firm recently collaborated with Edge Consult on a challenging design and build project, which became a learning ground for conflict resolution.
“Every construction project inevitably encounters hurdles,” Stanton began, a hint of amusement in his voice as if acknowledging an unspoken industry truth. “It’s not about avoiding problems entirely but managing them effectively when they arise.”
The project in question had faced significant delays, extending over a year. Despite the setbacks, the Employer’s Agent had only approved a four-month extension, leaving the contractor in a difficult position. The situation escalated with the imposition of substantial liquidated damages, a financial strain that could cripple any project.
“Edge Consult came on board when it became clear we needed expert guidance to navigate this quagmire,” Stanton explained. “Their role was pivotal in helping us articulate our case for additional extensions of time.”
He went on to describe how Edge Consult’s team delved into the intricacies of the project timeline, analysing every delay factor and its impact. Their detailed approach was not just about numbers but understanding the broader context of the delays. “They worked closely with our team, almost like an extension of our own staff,” Stanton noted, highlighting the importance of collaboration in such scenarios.
Despite the thorough groundwork, the Employer’s Agent remained unmoved, leading to an impasse that seemed insurmountable. “It was frustrating, to say the least,” Stanton admitted. “But Edge Consult had prepared us well for this possibility.”
The decision to move to adjudication was not taken lightly. Stanton elaborated on the considerations that influenced this course of action, emphasising the need for a clear, well-supported case. “Adjudication is a formal process, and you need to go in well-prepared,” he said. This was where Edge Consult’s expertise shone through, acting as the contractor’s Party Representative.
Stanton described the adjudication process as intense, with numerous exchanges and a meticulous review of evidence. “It was a learning curve,” he reflected. “Understanding the legal and procedural aspects was critical, and having a knowledgeable partner was invaluable.”
The adjudicator’s decision was a turning point. The contractor was granted a further 63-week extension, which not only validated their claims but also impacted the recoverable loss and expense. Importantly, almost all the deducted damages were ordered to be repaid. “It was a triumphant moment,” Stanton recalled, his satisfaction evident. “It reaffirmed the importance of having the right support and strategy.”
Beyond the immediate victory, Stanton stressed the broader lessons gleaned from the experience. “Conflict avoidance is always the goal, but when disputes arise, having a robust strategy is essential,” he advised. “Clear communication, comprehensive documentation, and expert guidance are the pillars of effective dispute resolution.”
Reflecting on the partnership with Edge Consult, Stanton praised their professionalism and strategic insight. “They brought a level of expertise that was crucial in navigating the complexities of the case,” he said. However, he was keen to point out that the lessons learned were applicable across the industry. “It’s about adopting a mindset that values preparation and proactive management.”
As our conversation drew to a close, I asked Stanton about his advice for other contractors facing similar challenges. His response was thoughtful and measured. “Invest in relationships with experts who understand the construction industry. It’s not just about resolving conflicts but avoiding them in the first place. And when disputes do occur, approach them with a strategic mindset.”
Mark Stanton’s insights provide a valuable perspective for anyone involved in construction projects. The experience underscored the critical role of strategic advice and expert partnerships in navigating the often turbulent waters of conflict and resolution. For building contractors, these lessons are not just about surviving disputes but thriving in an ever-evolving industry landscape.
Kenneth George
Be the first to comment