Holistic Energy Optimization in the Built Environment: Beyond BREEAM Certification

Abstract

The built environment is a significant contributor to global energy consumption and greenhouse gas emissions. Building Research Establishment Environmental Assessment Method (BREEAM) certification provides a valuable framework for promoting sustainable building practices, with energy efficiency playing a crucial role. However, a truly impactful approach to energy optimization necessitates a holistic perspective extending beyond the specific criteria of BREEAM and embracing emerging technologies, advanced modeling techniques, and a deeper understanding of occupant behavior. This research report explores advanced strategies for energy conservation in buildings, encompassing passive design principles, innovative material science, intelligent building systems, and renewable energy integration. It critically examines the limitations of current certification schemes and proposes a more comprehensive framework for achieving net-zero energy performance and enhancing the overall sustainability of the built environment. Furthermore, it analyzes the economic viability of advanced energy-saving technologies and explores the policy implications for fostering a more energy-efficient and sustainable building sector.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

1. Introduction

The urgency of addressing climate change demands a radical transformation of the built environment. Buildings account for a substantial portion of global energy demand and associated carbon emissions. While initiatives like BREEAM have driven significant improvements in building energy performance, a more profound and holistic approach is required to meet ambitious decarbonization targets. This approach must transcend prescriptive measures and embrace innovative strategies that optimize energy efficiency throughout the building lifecycle, from design and construction to operation and decommissioning.

BREEAM provides a valuable framework for assessing and certifying the environmental performance of buildings, with energy efficiency being a core component. However, the inherent limitations of certification schemes, including their reliance on specific criteria and potential for gaming the system, necessitate a more comprehensive and forward-looking perspective. This report argues that achieving genuine energy optimization requires a deeper understanding of building physics, advanced modeling techniques, and the integration of cutting-edge technologies.

The scope of this report extends beyond the immediate requirements of BREEAM to explore advanced strategies for energy conservation in buildings. It examines the potential of passive design principles to minimize energy demand, the role of innovative materials in enhancing thermal performance, the application of intelligent building systems for optimizing energy use, and the integration of renewable energy sources to achieve net-zero energy performance. Furthermore, it critically evaluates the economic feasibility of these advanced technologies and explores the policy implications for promoting their widespread adoption.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

2. Passive Solar Design and Natural Ventilation Strategies

Passive solar design is a cornerstone of energy-efficient building design, minimizing the need for mechanical heating and cooling by harnessing natural resources. This approach involves carefully considering the building’s orientation, glazing, shading, and thermal mass to optimize solar gains in winter and minimize solar heat gain in summer.

2.1. Building Orientation and Glazing: Optimal building orientation maximizes solar exposure during the heating season and minimizes it during the cooling season. South-facing orientations (in the Northern Hemisphere) generally provide the best solar access for winter heating. Strategic placement of glazing is crucial, with a higher proportion of glazing on the south facade and smaller windows on the east and west facades to minimize unwanted heat gain in the morning and afternoon. Low-emissivity (low-E) coatings on glazing can further reduce radiative heat transfer, enhancing thermal comfort and energy efficiency. Careful consideration needs to be given to local climate. In hot climates, shading and minimal western glazing is essential.

2.2. Shading Strategies: Effective shading strategies are essential for minimizing solar heat gain during the summer months. Overhangs, fins, and external shutters can effectively block direct sunlight from entering the building, reducing the cooling load. Deciduous trees planted strategically can provide natural shading during the summer and allow sunlight to penetrate during the winter when the leaves have fallen. Advanced shading devices, such as dynamic shading systems that adjust automatically based on solar position and weather conditions, can further optimize solar control.

2.3. Thermal Mass: Thermal mass refers to the ability of a material to store and release heat. High-thermal-mass materials, such as concrete, brick, and stone, can absorb solar heat during the day and release it slowly at night, moderating indoor temperature fluctuations. This is particularly effective in climates with significant diurnal temperature swings. The strategic placement of thermal mass within the building envelope is crucial for maximizing its effectiveness. While thermal mass is generally beneficial, it’s important to consider that the effectiveness of thermal mass depends on the climate.

2.4. Natural Ventilation: Natural ventilation is the process of using natural forces, such as wind and buoyancy, to provide fresh air and remove stale air from a building. Effective natural ventilation design requires careful consideration of building layout, window placement, and prevailing wind patterns. Operable windows, strategically located to promote cross-ventilation, are essential. Stack ventilation, which utilizes buoyancy forces to drive airflow, can be particularly effective in taller buildings. Natural ventilation can significantly reduce the need for mechanical ventilation and air conditioning, leading to substantial energy savings.

2.5 Case Study Considerations: The success of passive solar design depends heavily on climate. For example, whilst Thermal mass can be highly beneficial in a climate with large diurnal temperature swings, in a temperate climate with mild summers and winters it may provide little benefit. Passive solar design must be considered with respect to the specific climate of the build. It is an example of why BREEAM should be considered as a starting point and not the final solution, BREEAM can be implemented poorly without understanding basic building principles and climates.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

3. Advanced Building Materials and Insulation Technologies

The selection of appropriate building materials plays a crucial role in determining the energy performance of a building. Advanced materials and insulation technologies can significantly reduce heat transfer through the building envelope, minimizing energy demand for heating and cooling.

3.1. High-Performance Insulation: Advanced insulation materials, such as vacuum insulation panels (VIPs) and aerogels, offer significantly higher thermal resistance than conventional insulation materials, such as fiberglass and mineral wool. VIPs consist of a rigid core material encased in a hermetically sealed envelope, creating a vacuum that virtually eliminates heat transfer by conduction and convection. Aerogels are highly porous materials with extremely low densities, providing exceptional thermal insulation properties. While VIPs and aerogels offer superior performance, they are typically more expensive than conventional insulation materials. However, their higher thermal resistance can result in significant energy savings over the building’s lifetime.

3.2. Phase Change Materials (PCMs): PCMs are materials that absorb and release heat during a phase change, such as melting or freezing. When incorporated into building materials, PCMs can help to regulate indoor temperatures by absorbing excess heat during the day and releasing it at night. PCMs can be integrated into walls, ceilings, and floors, improving the thermal mass of the building envelope. PCMs can be particularly effective in reducing temperature fluctuations and improving thermal comfort.

3.3. Smart Windows: Smart windows are glazing systems that can dynamically adjust their properties in response to changing environmental conditions. Electrochromic windows, for example, can darken or lighten in response to an applied voltage, controlling the amount of sunlight and heat entering the building. Thermochromic windows change their properties in response to temperature, becoming more opaque as the temperature increases. Photochromic windows change their properties in response to light intensity. Smart windows can significantly reduce the need for artificial lighting and air conditioning, leading to energy savings and improved occupant comfort. The cost of smart windows is still a factor, however the price is decreasing as the technology becomes more mature.

3.4. Low-Emissivity Coatings: As mentioned previously, Low-E coatings on glazing reduce the amount of heat transferred through windows, thereby increasing the thermal efficiency of the building. Recent advances include spectrally selective coatings, which optimize the transmission of visible light while minimizing the transmission of infrared radiation.

3.5. Green Roofs: While often considered an aesthetic feature, green roofs can provide significant thermal insulation, reducing heat gain in summer and heat loss in winter. The soil and vegetation layer acts as a barrier to direct sunlight, reducing the roof’s surface temperature and the amount of heat transferred into the building. Green roofs also provide stormwater management benefits and improve air quality.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

4. Intelligent Building Systems and Energy Management

Intelligent building systems (IBS) leverage advanced sensors, controls, and data analytics to optimize energy consumption and improve building performance. These systems can monitor and control various building functions, such as lighting, HVAC, and occupancy, adapting to changing conditions and user needs.

4.1. Building Automation Systems (BAS): BAS are centralized control systems that manage and monitor various building systems, such as HVAC, lighting, and security. BAS can optimize energy consumption by automatically adjusting setpoints, schedules, and control strategies based on real-time data. For example, a BAS can automatically reduce lighting levels in unoccupied spaces or adjust HVAC settings based on occupancy patterns and weather forecasts. BAS also facilitate remote monitoring and control, allowing building managers to identify and address energy inefficiencies in a timely manner. A well configured BAS can adapt to the building usage, it is important to understand the building’s use patterns and make sure this is reflected in the configuration.

4.2. Advanced Lighting Controls: Advanced lighting controls can significantly reduce energy consumption for lighting. Occupancy sensors can automatically turn lights off in unoccupied spaces. Daylight harvesting systems can dim or turn off lights in response to natural daylight levels. Personal lighting controls allow occupants to adjust lighting levels to their individual preferences. These strategies can significantly reduce energy consumption for lighting, especially in commercial buildings.

4.3. Smart HVAC Systems: Smart HVAC systems utilize advanced sensors and controls to optimize HVAC performance and reduce energy consumption. Predictive control algorithms can anticipate future cooling and heating loads based on weather forecasts and occupancy patterns, proactively adjusting HVAC settings to minimize energy use. Zone control systems allow for independent control of temperature in different areas of the building, optimizing comfort and energy efficiency. Smart HVAC systems can also detect and diagnose equipment malfunctions, enabling timely maintenance and preventing energy waste.

4.4. Energy Monitoring and Analytics: Continuous energy monitoring and analytics are essential for identifying and addressing energy inefficiencies. Advanced metering infrastructure (AMI) provides real-time data on energy consumption, allowing building managers to track energy use patterns and identify areas for improvement. Energy analytics software can analyze energy data to identify anomalies, detect equipment malfunctions, and optimize building performance. Regular energy audits can also help to identify opportunities for energy savings.

4.5 Building Information Modeling (BIM): BIM is a digital representation of a building that can be used throughout the building lifecycle, from design and construction to operation and maintenance. BIM can be used to simulate building performance, identify potential energy inefficiencies, and optimize building design. BIM can also be integrated with BAS to provide real-time data on building performance and facilitate proactive energy management.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

5. Renewable Energy Integration

Integrating renewable energy sources into the built environment is crucial for achieving net-zero energy performance. Solar photovoltaic (PV) systems, solar thermal systems, and wind turbines can generate clean energy on-site, reducing reliance on fossil fuels and lowering carbon emissions.

5.1. Solar Photovoltaic (PV) Systems: Solar PV systems convert sunlight directly into electricity. PV panels can be installed on rooftops, facades, and ground-mounted arrays. Advances in PV technology have led to increased efficiency and lower costs, making solar PV an increasingly attractive option for building owners. Grid-connected PV systems can supply excess electricity back to the grid, generating revenue for building owners. Battery storage systems can store excess solar energy for later use, providing backup power and improving grid stability. Careful consideration needs to be given to the orientation and shading of the panels to ensure that the best efficiency can be obtained.

5.2. Solar Thermal Systems: Solar thermal systems use sunlight to heat water or air. Solar water heating systems can provide hot water for domestic use, reducing the need for conventional water heaters. Solar air heating systems can preheat ventilation air, reducing the load on HVAC systems. Solar thermal systems are particularly cost-effective in climates with high solar irradiance. Some Solar Thermal Systems use concentrated solar power to generate high temperature steam, this has the potential to reduce building energy consumption further but requires more space to implement.

5.3. Wind Turbines: Small-scale wind turbines can generate electricity on-site, reducing reliance on the grid. Wind turbines are typically installed on rooftops or on the ground. The feasibility of wind turbine installation depends on wind resource availability and local zoning regulations. Vertical-axis wind turbines (VAWTs) are often preferred for urban environments due to their smaller size and lower noise levels. Offshore wind farms are more common due to the higher wind speed that is available off shore.

5.4. Geothermal Energy: Geothermal energy utilizes the earth’s constant subsurface temperature to provide heating and cooling. Geothermal heat pumps can extract heat from the ground in winter and reject heat into the ground in summer, providing efficient heating and cooling. Geothermal energy is a reliable and sustainable energy source with minimal environmental impact. Geothermal energy systems can be more expensive than conventional HVAC systems, but the lower operating costs can result in long-term savings.

5.5. Hybrid Renewable Energy Systems: Combining multiple renewable energy sources can provide a more reliable and resilient energy supply. For example, a hybrid system might combine solar PV with wind turbines and battery storage. Hybrid systems can be designed to meet specific energy needs and optimize energy production and storage.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

6. Occupant Behavior and Energy Awareness

Occupant behavior has a significant impact on building energy consumption. Promoting energy awareness and encouraging occupants to adopt energy-saving behaviors can lead to substantial reductions in energy use.

6.1. Energy Feedback Systems: Energy feedback systems provide occupants with real-time information on their energy consumption. These systems can display energy use data on screens, mobile devices, or web interfaces. Energy feedback can motivate occupants to reduce their energy consumption by making them more aware of their energy use patterns. Comparative feedback, which compares energy use to that of similar buildings or users, can be particularly effective.

6.2. Education and Training: Educating occupants about energy-saving strategies and providing training on how to use building systems efficiently can lead to significant energy savings. Training programs can cover topics such as turning off lights when leaving a room, adjusting thermostat settings, and using appliances efficiently. Regular communication and engagement with occupants can reinforce energy-saving behaviors.

6.3. Incentives and Rewards: Providing incentives and rewards for energy-saving behaviors can further motivate occupants to reduce their energy consumption. Incentives can include discounts on rent or utilities, gift cards, or recognition programs. Gamification, which uses game-like elements to encourage participation, can also be effective.

6.4. Smart Home Technologies: Smart home technologies can automate energy-saving tasks and provide occupants with greater control over their energy use. Smart thermostats can automatically adjust temperature settings based on occupancy and weather conditions. Smart plugs can automatically turn off appliances when they are not in use. Smart lighting systems can automatically dim or turn off lights based on occupancy and daylight levels. These technologies can simplify energy management and make it easier for occupants to save energy.

6.5. Human-Centered Design: Designing buildings that are comfortable, user-friendly, and responsive to occupant needs can also promote energy efficiency. Natural lighting, comfortable temperatures, and good indoor air quality can reduce the need for artificial lighting and HVAC. Ergonomic design can reduce strain and improve productivity, which can also lead to energy savings.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

7. Economic Feasibility and Financial Benefits

Investing in energy-saving technologies can result in significant long-term financial benefits. While the initial cost of some advanced technologies may be higher than conventional options, the reduced energy consumption and operating costs can result in a rapid payback. Many governments and utilities offer incentives, such as tax credits, rebates, and grants, to encourage the adoption of energy-efficient technologies.

7.1. Life-Cycle Cost Analysis (LCCA): LCCA is a method for evaluating the total cost of an investment over its entire lifespan. LCCA takes into account not only the initial cost of the investment but also the operating costs, maintenance costs, and replacement costs. LCCA can be used to compare the economic feasibility of different energy-saving technologies and to determine the optimal investment strategy.

7.2. Return on Investment (ROI): ROI is a measure of the profitability of an investment. ROI is calculated by dividing the net profit by the cost of the investment. A higher ROI indicates a more profitable investment. ROI can be used to compare the economic feasibility of different energy-saving technologies and to justify investments in energy efficiency.

7.3. Payback Period: Payback period is the time it takes for an investment to pay for itself. Payback period is calculated by dividing the cost of the investment by the annual savings. A shorter payback period indicates a more attractive investment. Payback period can be used to evaluate the economic feasibility of different energy-saving technologies and to determine the optimal investment strategy.

7.4. Energy Performance Contracting (EPC): EPC is a financing mechanism that allows building owners to implement energy-saving projects without upfront capital investment. Under an EPC agreement, an energy service company (ESCO) guarantees energy savings and is paid a percentage of the savings over a specified period. EPC can be a valuable tool for promoting energy efficiency in buildings with limited capital budgets.

7.5. Green Building Certifications and Property Value: Studies have shown that green building certifications, such as BREEAM, can increase property value. Green buildings are often perceived as being more desirable to tenants and buyers due to their lower operating costs, improved indoor environmental quality, and enhanced sustainability. The increased property value can provide a significant return on investment for building owners.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

8. Policy Implications and Regulatory Frameworks

Government policies and regulations play a crucial role in promoting energy efficiency in the built environment. Building codes, energy efficiency standards, and incentive programs can drive the adoption of energy-saving technologies and practices.

8.1. Building Codes and Energy Efficiency Standards: Building codes and energy efficiency standards set minimum requirements for building energy performance. These regulations can be prescriptive, specifying specific requirements for building components and systems, or performance-based, setting target energy consumption levels for the entire building. Strong building codes and energy efficiency standards are essential for driving energy efficiency improvements in new construction.

8.2. Incentive Programs: Incentive programs can encourage building owners to invest in energy-saving technologies and practices. Incentives can include tax credits, rebates, grants, and loan programs. Incentive programs can be targeted at specific technologies or building types. Effective incentive programs can significantly accelerate the adoption of energy-efficient technologies.

8.3. Carbon Pricing Mechanisms: Carbon pricing mechanisms, such as carbon taxes and cap-and-trade systems, can create a financial incentive for reducing carbon emissions from buildings. Carbon taxes impose a fee on carbon emissions, while cap-and-trade systems set a limit on total emissions and allow companies to trade emission allowances. Carbon pricing mechanisms can encourage building owners to invest in energy efficiency and renewable energy to reduce their carbon footprint.

8.4. Energy Audits and Disclosure Requirements: Energy audits and disclosure requirements can promote transparency and accountability in building energy performance. Energy audits provide a detailed assessment of a building’s energy consumption and identify opportunities for energy savings. Disclosure requirements require building owners to disclose their building’s energy performance to potential tenants or buyers. These policies can encourage building owners to improve their building’s energy performance.

8.5. Public Awareness Campaigns: Public awareness campaigns can educate consumers about the benefits of energy efficiency and encourage them to adopt energy-saving behaviors. These campaigns can use various media, such as television, radio, print, and the internet, to reach a wide audience. Effective public awareness campaigns can change consumer attitudes and behaviors, leading to increased demand for energy-efficient products and services.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

9. Conclusion

Achieving significant reductions in building energy consumption requires a holistic approach that extends beyond the specific criteria of BREEAM certification. This approach must encompass advanced passive design strategies, innovative material science, intelligent building systems, renewable energy integration, and a focus on occupant behavior. By embracing these strategies and implementing supportive policies, we can create a more energy-efficient and sustainable built environment that contributes to a low-carbon future. While BREEAM is a useful standard, it is important that those specifying and implementing it understand the underlying building physics and use it only as a starting point when designing energy efficient buildings.

Furthermore, whilst energy is a crucial factor in environmental sustainability, other factors must be considered. It would be easy to reduce the carbon footprint of a building through using highly insulating materials however if this were to result in greater deforestation, or require materials that have travelled vast distances this would be counterproductive. Every aspect of a building from the materials to the building’s function and its interaction with the environment should be considered.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

References

• BREEAM
• U.S. Department of Energy, Building Technologies Office
• Whole Building Design Guide
• International Energy Agency (IEA)
• Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC)
• Passive House Institute
• ASHRAE
• Turner, C., & Frankel, M. (2008). Energy performance of LEED for new construction buildings. Energy and Buildings, 40(7), 1214-1224.
• Pérez-Lombard, L., Ortiz, J., & Pout, C. (2008). A review on buildings energy consumption information. Energy and Buildings, 40(3), 394-398.
• Roodman, D. M., & Lenssen, N. (1995). A building revolution: How ecology and health concerns are transforming construction. Worldwatch Institute.
• Deng, S., Wang, R. Z., & Dai, Y. J. (2011). A review on phase change materials for passive solar heating and cooling of buildings. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 15(2), 730-742.
• Goia, F., Haapala, K. R., & Dillet, A. (2013). Dynamic energy performance assessment of electrochromic windows. Applied Energy, 102, 982-993.
• Kibert, C. J. (2016). Sustainable construction: Green building design and delivery. John Wiley & Sons.