BREEAM vs LEED: 10 Differences

Summary

This article clarifies 10 key differences between BREEAM and LEED certifications, including geographic prevalence, assessment focus, and cost. It guides you on choosing the best certification for your project and provides actionable steps to achieve BREEAM certification. Whether you’re aiming for BREEAM or LEED, this guide equips you with the knowledge to make informed decisions.

Discover how Focus360 Energy can help with BREEAM certification.

** Main Story**

BREEAM vs LEED: Unlocking Greener Buildings

Navigating the world of green building certifications can feel like traversing a maze. Two prominent systems, BREEAM and LEED, often dominate the conversation, leaving many wondering about their differences and which path to choose. This article illuminates 10 key distinctions between BREEAM and LEED, empowering you to select the best fit for your project. We also lay out a clear roadmap for achieving BREEAM certification, turning a daunting task into manageable steps.

10 Key Differences: BREEAM vs LEED

• Geographic Focus: LEED primarily dominates North America, while BREEAM holds stronger sway in the UK and Europe, though both have international presence.
• Assessment Scope: BREEAM assesses a wider range of sustainability aspects, including ecology, transport, and management, adopting a more holistic approach. LEED prioritizes energy efficiency and indoor environmental quality.
• Scoring System: LEED uses a points-based system with percentage thresholds, while BREEAM employs a weighted scoring system with quantitative benchmarks, offering a more nuanced approach.
• Certification Process: BREEAM mandates using licensed assessors to evaluate projects, streamlining the process for applicants. LEED, conversely, tasks project teams with collecting and submitting data for review.
• Building Types: BREEAM offers certification schemes tailored to various building uses (e.g., industrial, retail, healthcare), providing specialized assessments. LEED categorizes certifications by project stage (e.g., new construction, existing buildings, interiors).
• Standards and Regulations: LEED aligns with American ASHRAE standards, while BREEAM adheres to European and UK regulations, reflecting regional differences.
• Rigor and Complexity: BREEAM generally demands greater rigor, with its “Outstanding” rating considered more challenging than LEED’s “Platinum” level.
• Cost: Both certifications entail costs, but specifics vary depending on project scope and location. BREEAM’s upfront costs, including assessor fees, are usually higher, while LEED might involve more hidden expenses related to documentation and architectural review.
• Flexibility: BREEAM offers more flexibility in achieving certification. Projects can compensate for lower performance in one area by excelling in others. LEED mandates stricter compliance with prerequisite requirements.
• Market Recognition: While LEED enjoys wider global name recognition due to its prevalence in numerous countries, BREEAM boasts a higher number of certified buildings within Europe.

Choosing the Right Certification:

Selecting between BREEAM and LEED depends on various factors: project location, specific sustainability goals, budget, and familiarity with the respective standards. For projects in the UK and Europe, BREEAM often presents the more logical choice due to its alignment with local regulations and cost-effectiveness. In North America, LEED might be more advantageous due to its wider market acceptance and established network of professionals.

Achieving BREEAM Certification: A Step-by-Step Guide

1. Define Your Goals: Clearly outline your sustainability aspirations and the desired BREEAM rating (Pass, Good, Very Good, Excellent, or Outstanding).
2. Engage a BREEAM Assessor: Enlist a licensed BREEAM assessor early in the project. Their expertise proves invaluable in navigating the certification process and optimizing your strategy.
3. Conduct a Pre-Assessment: A pre-assessment provides a baseline evaluation, identifies areas for improvement, and estimates your potential BREEAM rating.
4. Develop a BREEAM Strategy: Formulate a detailed plan addressing each BREEAM category. Focus on maximizing credits within your budget and project constraints.
5. Implement Sustainable Design and Construction Practices: Embrace energy-efficient design, water conservation strategies, responsible material selection, and waste reduction measures.
6. Document and Gather Evidence: Meticulously document all sustainability initiatives and gather the necessary evidence to demonstrate compliance with BREEAM criteria.
7. Submit for Final Assessment: Your assessor will compile and submit the complete documentation package to BRE for final review and certification.

BREEAM Certification: Beyond the Basics

• Focus on Whole-Life Cycle Assessment: Consider the environmental impact of materials and building systems throughout their entire life cycle, from sourcing to disposal.
• Maximize Water Efficiency: Implement water-saving fixtures, rainwater harvesting, and greywater recycling systems.
• Prioritize Indoor Environmental Quality: Optimize ventilation, natural light, and thermal comfort for occupants’ health and well-being.
• Enhance Transport Accessibility: Promote sustainable transportation options, such as cycling, public transit, and electric vehicle charging stations.

By following these steps and incorporating these advanced considerations, you can successfully navigate the BREEAM certification process and create a truly sustainable building. This not only benefits the environment but also enhances your project’s market value and demonstrates your commitment to responsible development.