Summary
This article guides you through the criticisms of BREEAM and LEED, offering actionable steps to navigate these certifications effectively. It emphasizes a holistic approach to sustainability, prioritizing embodied carbon and whole-life cycle analysis. By understanding these key areas, you can achieve true sustainability and maximize the value of your green building certifications.
Discover how Focus360 Energy can help with BREEAM certification.
** Main Story**
So, you’re thinking about getting a green building certification like BREEAM or LEED, huh? They’ve become pretty popular in construction, and for good reason – they offer a framework for more sustainable practices. But, and it’s a big ‘but’, there’s been some criticism, particularly around embodied carbon and, well, potential greenwashing. Let’s dive in.
The Skeptic’s Corner
You might have heard the arguments already. Architect Andrew Waugh, for example, wasn’t shy about calling BREEAM and LEED “meaningless”, mainly because of how they handle embodied carbon. What’s embodied carbon? It’s all the emissions from making materials, hauling them around, and actually building the thing. Sure, operational emissions—like the energy a building uses day-to-day—are crucial. But embodied carbon can be a huge chunk of a building’s total impact. If you only focus on operational stuff, you’re not getting the full picture, are you?
Then there’s the risk of ‘greenwashing’. Sometimes, developers just chase certifications for the marketing boost, and, I mean, who can blame them? But they might just throw in some easy, visible ‘green’ features to rack up points, while skipping the tougher, but more impactful sustainable choices. It’s a bit like putting solar panels on a gas-guzzling SUV, right?
Getting Real Value
So, how do you make sure your certification actually means something and you’re not just playing at sustainability? Here’s what I reckon:
-
Embodied Carbon First: Do a thorough life cycle assessment (LCA). Figure out exactly what the embodied carbon footprint of your project is. Then, look at materials with lower carbon footprints – think sustainably sourced timber or recycled stuff. And streamline your construction to cut down on waste, because that’s also going to reduce emissions.
-
Think Long Term: Take a whole-life cycle approach. From the initial design to when the building’s eventually torn down, plan everything. Design for deconstruction, so materials can be reused later. Prioritize durable materials and efficient systems to keep operational emissions down for years to come. You don’t want to be replacing equipment every five years. It’s costly and it’s just wasteful.
-
Don’t Just Meet the Minimum: Certifications are a game of points, but try, if you can, to go above the minimum requirements for that shiny certification. Think about innovative tech, and new strategies that could really push boundaries of what we think of green building. For example, I worked on a project a couple of years ago where we implemented a grey water recycling system, and whilst this was not necessary for certification it has reduced water consumption of the building drastically.
-
Performance Matters More Than Points: Certifications, after all, are a way to an end, not the end itself. Your goal? A truly sustainable building that has the least impact on the environment. So, measure real performance, instead of just focusing on the score. This is crucial, because then you are actively creating a building that is better for the environment.
-
Be Transparent: Show your work. Transparency in sustainability reporting builds trust. Get a third-party to verify your environmental claims so everyone knows you’re legit.
The Bigger Picture
If you can tackle the embodied carbon issue, take a full life cycle view, and really focus on genuine performance, your green building certification won’t just be a badge; it’ll mean something real. Embracing a whole-life cycle perspective, and focusing on genuine performance; this will create buildings that aren’t only certified as green but buildings that are also truly sustainable. As of today, May 5, 2025, it’s essential we take these steps seriously to navigate the complex world of green building certifications and build a genuinely sustainable future. Isn’t that what we all want, in the end?
So, a grey water system not *needed* for certification but drastically cuts consumption? Sounds like you were playing chess while everyone else was playing checkers! Maybe BREEAM and LEED need a “thinking outside the tap” bonus.
That’s a great way to put it! The “thinking outside the tap” bonus is exactly what’s needed. It’s about looking beyond the minimum requirements and focusing on innovative solutions like grey water systems to achieve genuine sustainability and improve performance. Let’s encourage more of that kind of thinking in green building!
Editor: FocusNews.Uk
Thank you to our Sponsor Focus 360 Energy
The emphasis on whole-life cycle analysis is vital. Considering deconstruction and material reuse at the design stage can significantly reduce environmental impact and promote a circular economy within the construction industry.