Heat Pumps in the UK’s Decarbonization Strategy: Technology, Integration, and Future Directions

Abstract

As the UK strives to meet its ambitious net-zero emissions targets, the Future Homes Standard mandates the adoption of low-carbon heating solutions in new builds, positioning heat pumps as a cornerstone technology. This research report provides a comprehensive analysis of heat pumps within the broader context of the UK’s decarbonization strategy. It delves into the diverse types of heat pumps (air source, ground source, and hybrid systems), their operational efficiency, installation and maintenance costs, environmental impact (including refrigerant considerations), and suitability across varying housing archetypes in the UK. Furthermore, the report critically compares heat pumps with other low-carbon heating technologies such as solar thermal, district heating, and hydrogen-based systems, considering factors like technological maturity, economic viability, and infrastructure requirements. The report also explores the critical role of heat networks and energy storage in enhancing the performance and reliability of heat pump systems. Finally, the paper examines the policy and regulatory landscape, highlighting current incentives and challenges, and proposing future directions for accelerating the deployment of heat pumps and facilitating a wider transition to low-carbon heating in the UK.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

1. Introduction

The urgency to mitigate climate change has propelled the UK government to set legally binding targets for reducing greenhouse gas emissions. Decarbonizing the heating sector, which accounts for a significant portion of the UK’s carbon footprint, is paramount to achieving these targets. The Future Homes Standard, aimed at ensuring that new homes are zero-carbon ready, designates heat pumps as a key technology for low-carbon heating. This mandate necessitates a thorough understanding of heat pump technologies, their performance characteristics, and their suitability for the UK context. The transition to widespread heat pump adoption is not without its challenges, including high upfront costs, installation complexities, and public perception. This report aims to provide a comprehensive overview of heat pumps in the UK, addressing these challenges and exploring the opportunities for their effective integration into the national energy system.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

2. Heat Pump Technologies: A Detailed Overview

Heat pumps are devices that transfer heat from a source to a sink, utilizing a thermodynamic cycle. They can provide both heating and cooling, making them versatile solutions for residential and commercial buildings. The efficiency of a heat pump is quantified by its Coefficient of Performance (COP), which is the ratio of heat output to electrical energy input. A higher COP indicates greater efficiency. Different types of heat pumps exist, each with its own advantages and disadvantages:

2.1 Air Source Heat Pumps (ASHPs)

ASHPs extract heat from the ambient air, even at low temperatures. They are relatively easy to install and generally have lower upfront costs compared to other heat pump types. However, their efficiency can decrease significantly during cold weather, requiring supplementary heating in some cases. Different types of ASHPs exist, including air-to-air and air-to-water systems. Air-to-air systems directly heat the air within a building, while air-to-water systems heat water, which can then be used for radiators or underfloor heating. The performance of ASHPs is highly dependent on the climate. In regions with extremely cold winters, their COP can drop considerably, leading to increased electricity consumption.

2.2 Ground Source Heat Pumps (GSHPs)

GSHPs, also known as geothermal heat pumps, utilize the stable temperature of the earth as a heat source (or sink). They can be installed using horizontal loops, vertical boreholes, or ground water systems. GSHPs offer higher efficiency and more consistent performance compared to ASHPs, as the ground temperature remains relatively constant throughout the year. However, GSHPs have higher installation costs due to the need for ground excavation or drilling. Furthermore, the geology of the site can significantly impact the feasibility and cost of GSHP installation.

2.3 Hybrid Heat Pumps

Hybrid heat pumps combine a heat pump with a conventional heating system, such as a gas boiler. These systems are designed to use the heat pump as the primary heating source, with the boiler providing supplementary heat during periods of peak demand or when the outside temperature is too low for the heat pump to operate efficiently. Hybrid systems can offer a cost-effective solution for retrofitting existing buildings, as they can utilize existing heating infrastructure and minimize disruption. However, the overall efficiency of a hybrid system depends on the control strategy used to manage the operation of the heat pump and the boiler.

2.4 Emerging Heat Pump Technologies

Beyond the established technologies, research and development efforts are focused on improving the performance and reducing the cost of heat pumps. These include:

• CO2 Heat Pumps: Utilizing CO2 as a refrigerant, these systems offer high efficiency and lower environmental impact compared to traditional refrigerants. CO2 has a low global warming potential (GWP) and is non-flammable.
• Absorption Heat Pumps: These systems use a heat source, such as solar thermal energy or waste heat, to drive the thermodynamic cycle, reducing the reliance on electricity.
• Thermally Driven Heat Pumps: These heat pumps are powered by thermal energy, such as solar thermal or waste heat, instead of electricity. This can be particularly advantageous in industrial applications where waste heat is readily available.
• High-Temperature Heat Pumps: These are designed to deliver higher water temperatures, making them suitable for retrofitting buildings with existing heating systems designed for higher supply temperatures. They are particularly useful in industrial processes.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

3. Efficiency and Performance Analysis

The efficiency of a heat pump is a critical factor in determining its overall environmental impact and operating costs. The COP is a widely used metric for measuring heat pump efficiency, but it is important to consider the operating conditions under which the COP is measured. The Seasonal Coefficient of Performance (SCOP) and Seasonal Energy Efficiency Ratio (SEER) provide a more realistic assessment of heat pump performance over an entire heating or cooling season. These metrics take into account variations in temperature and load.

Factors that influence heat pump efficiency include:

• Climate: The ambient temperature significantly affects the performance of ASHPs. In colder climates, the COP of ASHPs decreases, leading to increased electricity consumption. GSHPs are less affected by climate due to the stable ground temperature.
• Heat Pump Design: The design and components of the heat pump, such as the compressor, heat exchangers, and control system, can significantly impact its efficiency. High-efficiency heat pumps typically incorporate advanced technologies such as variable-speed compressors and electronic expansion valves.
• Installation Quality: Proper installation is crucial for optimal heat pump performance. Incorrect sizing, poor insulation, and inadequate airflow can reduce efficiency and increase operating costs.
• Refrigerant: The type of refrigerant used in the heat pump can affect its efficiency and environmental impact. Newer refrigerants with lower GWP are being developed to replace traditional refrigerants with high GWP.
• System Integration: The way a heat pump is integrated with the building’s heating and cooling system can influence its performance. For example, using a low-temperature heating system, such as underfloor heating, can improve the efficiency of the heat pump.

3.1 Impact of Climate Change on Heat Pump Performance

Climate change is expected to impact the performance of heat pumps in the UK. Warmer winters may reduce the heating demand and improve the efficiency of ASHPs, while hotter summers may increase the cooling demand. However, more extreme weather events, such as heatwaves and cold snaps, could also impact the reliability and performance of heat pumps. It is important to design and install heat pump systems that can withstand these climate-related challenges.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

4. Installation Costs and Maintenance Requirements

The upfront cost of installing a heat pump can be a significant barrier to adoption, especially for homeowners. The cost varies depending on the type of heat pump, the size of the system, and the complexity of the installation. ASHPs generally have lower installation costs than GSHPs, but GSHPs offer lower operating costs due to their higher efficiency.

4.1 Cost Breakdown

A typical heat pump installation cost includes:

• Equipment Costs: The cost of the heat pump unit itself, including the compressor, heat exchangers, and control system.
• Installation Labor: The cost of labor for installing the heat pump, including electrical wiring, plumbing, and ductwork (if applicable).
• Groundworks (for GSHPs): The cost of excavating or drilling for GSHP installations, which can be a significant expense.
• System Design and Engineering: The cost of designing and engineering the heat pump system to ensure it meets the building’s heating and cooling needs.
• Permitting and Inspections: The cost of obtaining permits and inspections required by local authorities.

4.2 Maintenance Requirements

Heat pumps require regular maintenance to ensure optimal performance and longevity. Typical maintenance tasks include:

• Filter Cleaning or Replacement: Air filters should be cleaned or replaced regularly to maintain airflow and prevent dust buildup.
• Coil Cleaning: The outdoor coil of an ASHP should be cleaned periodically to remove dirt and debris.
• Refrigerant Check: The refrigerant level should be checked periodically to ensure proper operation.
• System Inspection: A qualified technician should inspect the system annually to identify and address any potential problems.

Proper maintenance can extend the lifespan of a heat pump and prevent costly repairs. It is important to choose a reputable installer who can provide ongoing maintenance and support.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

5. Environmental Impact: Refrigerants and Life Cycle Analysis

While heat pumps are generally considered to be environmentally friendly, their environmental impact is not zero. The primary environmental concerns associated with heat pumps are:

• Refrigerant Emissions: Traditional refrigerants used in heat pumps have high GWP, meaning that even small leaks can contribute significantly to climate change. Newer refrigerants with lower GWP are being developed and implemented.
• Electricity Consumption: The electricity used to power heat pumps can contribute to carbon emissions, depending on the source of electricity. Using renewable energy sources, such as solar or wind power, can significantly reduce the carbon footprint of heat pumps.
• Manufacturing and Disposal: The manufacturing and disposal of heat pump components can also have environmental impacts. It is important to consider the entire life cycle of the heat pump when assessing its environmental impact.

5.1 Refrigerant Regulations and Alternatives

The European Union has implemented regulations to phase out refrigerants with high GWP. The F-Gas Regulation aims to reduce emissions of fluorinated greenhouse gases, including hydrofluorocarbons (HFCs), which are commonly used in heat pumps. Alternative refrigerants with lower GWP include:

• R290 (Propane): A natural refrigerant with very low GWP and excellent thermodynamic properties. However, it is flammable and requires careful handling and installation.
• R32: A refrigerant with lower GWP than traditional HFCs, but still higher than R290. It is widely used in ASHPs.
• CO2 (Carbon Dioxide): A natural refrigerant with very low GWP and non-flammable. It is used in some high-temperature heat pumps.

The transition to low-GWP refrigerants is crucial for minimizing the environmental impact of heat pumps. Manufacturers are actively developing and implementing new refrigerants to comply with regulations and reduce greenhouse gas emissions.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

6. Suitability for Various Housing Types in the UK

The suitability of heat pumps for different housing types in the UK depends on several factors, including:

• Building Insulation: Well-insulated buildings require less heating and cooling, making heat pumps more efficient and cost-effective.
• Heating System: Heat pumps are most efficient when used with low-temperature heating systems, such as underfloor heating or large radiators. Buildings with existing high-temperature heating systems may require modifications to accommodate heat pumps.
• Space Availability: ASHPs require outdoor space for the outdoor unit, while GSHPs require space for ground loops or boreholes. Space constraints can limit the feasibility of heat pump installation.
• Building Age: Older buildings may require retrofitting to improve insulation and upgrade the heating system before installing a heat pump.

6.1 New Builds vs. Retrofit Applications

Heat pumps are particularly well-suited for new builds, as they can be integrated into the building design from the outset. This allows for optimal sizing, efficient system integration, and the use of low-temperature heating systems. Retrofitting existing buildings with heat pumps can be more challenging, as it may require modifications to the building envelope and heating system. However, hybrid heat pump systems can offer a cost-effective solution for retrofitting existing buildings.

6.2 Specific Housing Types

• Detached Houses: Detached houses generally have ample space for ASHP or GSHP installations. However, older detached houses may require significant retrofitting to improve insulation.
• Semi-Detached Houses: Semi-detached houses may have limited space for outdoor units or ground loops. ASHPs are generally more suitable for semi-detached houses.
• Terraced Houses: Terraced houses often have limited space and may require careful planning to install a heat pump. ASHPs can be installed on walls or roofs, but noise considerations should be taken into account.
• Apartments: Installing heat pumps in apartments can be challenging due to space constraints and regulatory issues. District heating systems or communal heat pumps may be more suitable for apartments.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

7. Comparison with Other Low-Carbon Heating Options

Heat pumps are not the only low-carbon heating option available in the UK. Other technologies include:

7.1 Solar Thermal

Solar thermal systems use solar collectors to heat water, which can then be used for domestic hot water or space heating. Solar thermal systems are most effective in regions with high solar irradiance. They can be integrated with heat pumps to provide a hybrid heating system.

7.2 District Heating

District heating systems distribute heat from a central source to multiple buildings. The heat source can be a combined heat and power (CHP) plant, a biomass boiler, or a geothermal plant. District heating systems can provide a cost-effective and efficient way to heat urban areas. In combination with heat pumps, they can extract heat from waste sources and distribute to customers. Many district heating schemes use large scale heat pumps.

7.3 Hydrogen-Based Heating

Hydrogen can be used as a fuel for heating, either in boilers or fuel cells. Hydrogen can be produced from renewable energy sources, making it a low-carbon alternative to natural gas. However, the infrastructure for hydrogen production and distribution is still under development.

7.4 Considerations for Choosing a Heating System

The choice of heating system depends on several factors, including:

• Cost: The upfront and operating costs of the system.
• Efficiency: The energy efficiency of the system.
• Environmental Impact: The carbon footprint of the system.
• Space Availability: The space required for the system.
• Infrastructure: The availability of infrastructure, such as gas pipelines or district heating networks.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

8. The Role of Heat Networks and Energy Storage

Heat networks and energy storage can play a crucial role in enhancing the performance and reliability of heat pump systems. Heat networks can connect multiple buildings to a central heat source, such as a large-scale heat pump or a CHP plant. This allows for economies of scale and improved efficiency. Energy storage can store excess heat or electricity, which can then be used to meet peak demand or to balance the grid. Thermal energy storage can be particularly useful in combination with heat pumps, as it can store heat generated during off-peak hours and release it during peak hours.

8.1 Types of Energy Storage

• Thermal Energy Storage (TES): Stores heat or cold for later use. TES can be implemented using various technologies, such as hot water tanks, ice storage, or phase-change materials (PCMs).
• Electrical Energy Storage (EES): Stores electricity for later use. EES can be implemented using batteries, pumped hydro storage, or compressed air energy storage.

8.2 Integrating Heat Pumps with Heat Networks and Energy Storage

Integrating heat pumps with heat networks and energy storage can provide several benefits:

• Increased Efficiency: Heat networks can improve the efficiency of heat pumps by allowing them to operate at optimal conditions.
• Reduced Costs: Energy storage can reduce the operating costs of heat pumps by allowing them to take advantage of off-peak electricity prices.
• Improved Reliability: Energy storage can provide backup power or heat in case of a power outage or equipment failure.
• Grid Flexibility: Heat pumps and energy storage can provide grid flexibility by responding to changes in electricity demand and supply.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

9. Policy and Regulatory Landscape in the UK

The UK government has implemented several policies and regulations to promote the adoption of heat pumps and decarbonize the heating sector. These include:

• Future Homes Standard: Mandates the use of low-carbon heating systems in new homes.
• Boiler Upgrade Scheme: Provides grants to homeowners to replace their gas boilers with heat pumps.
• Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI): Provided financial incentives for the generation of renewable heat, including heat from heat pumps (now closed to new applicants).
• Energy Company Obligation (ECO): Requires energy suppliers to promote energy efficiency measures, including heat pump installations.

9.1 Challenges and Future Directions

Despite these policies, there are still several challenges to overcome in order to accelerate the deployment of heat pumps in the UK:

• High Upfront Costs: The high upfront cost of heat pumps remains a barrier to adoption, particularly for low-income households.
• Lack of Awareness: Many consumers are not aware of the benefits of heat pumps or how they work.
• Installation Complexity: Installing heat pumps can be complex and requires skilled installers.
• Refrigerant Concerns: The environmental impact of refrigerants remains a concern.

To address these challenges, the UK government should:

• Increase Financial Incentives: Increase the level of financial incentives for heat pump installations, particularly for low-income households.
• Raise Awareness: Launch public awareness campaigns to educate consumers about the benefits of heat pumps.
• Train Installers: Invest in training programs to increase the number of qualified heat pump installers.
• Support Research and Development: Support research and development of new heat pump technologies, including low-GWP refrigerants.
• Streamline Permitting: Simplify the permitting process for heat pump installations.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

10. Conclusion

Heat pumps are a key technology for decarbonizing the heating sector in the UK. They offer high efficiency, low environmental impact, and versatility for both heating and cooling. While there are challenges to overcome, such as high upfront costs and installation complexities, the UK government has implemented several policies to promote the adoption of heat pumps. By addressing these challenges and continuing to support the development and deployment of heat pump technologies, the UK can achieve its ambitious net-zero emissions targets and create a more sustainable future.

Many thanks to our sponsor Focus 360 Energy who helped us prepare this research report.

References

• BEIS. (2021). Heat and Buildings Strategy. Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy.
• Committee on Climate Change. (2020). Sixth Carbon Budget. Committee on Climate Change.
• Energy Saving Trust. (2023). Heat Pumps. https://energysavingtrust.org.uk/
• European Environment Agency. (2022). Fluorinated Greenhouse Gases. https://www.eea.europa.eu/
• IEA. (2022). The Future of Heat Pumps. International Energy Agency.
• Ofgem. (2023). Energy Company Obligation (ECO). https://www.ofgem.gov.uk/
• RECC. (2023). Renewable Energy Consumer Code. https://www.recc.org.uk/
• Carbon Trust. (2023). Heat Pumps: Understanding the Technology and its Potential. https://www.carbontrust.com/
• Hepbasli, A., & Kalinci, Y. (2009). A review of heat pump systems. Energy, 34(5), 541-561.
• Radermacher, R., Hwang, Y., & Kauffeld, M. (2006). Vapor compression heat pumps with refrigerant mixtures. CRC press.
• Miriel, J., van Dijk, D., & Worall, R. (2017). Hybrid heat pump systems: A review. Renewable and Sustainable Energy Reviews, 76, 1159-1172.